Content Menu
Case Centre
Home > Case Centre > IJCSM > Reviewers

Reviewers

The work of reviewers is essential to the Journal and to the double-blind peer review process. As such, we are extremely grateful to all of the reviewers who contribute to the IJCSM, especially in a context where activities related to teaching and pedagogy are often given lower priority than research activities and publications.

The IJCSM relies on hundreds of reviewers affiliated with 77 universities in 15 countries. Historically, HEC Montréal professors have accounted for a significant proportion of the Journal’s reviewers. The majority of IJCSM reviewers are professors of management, but their ranks also include a number of consultants, managers and business leaders.

Reviewing a case for the IJCSM is an ideal way to familiarize oneself with the Journal’s editorial policy and to gain an understanding of how to go about producing and improving a case and teaching notes. This explains why the best case authors are often also reviewers.

For the sake of transparency and to encourage learning, the Journal sends each reviewer the evaluations of the other reviewers (generally three) of a case, as well as the letter sent by the editor to the case authors.

As a small token of its appreciation of reviewers, each year, the Journal publishes a list of the reviewers who contributed evaluations over the previous year.

+  Instructions for reviewers

 

  • Make sure you separate your comments on the case from those on the teaching notes (two distinct sections);
  • Begin by highlighting the strengths or positive aspects of the case or teaching notes. What did you like?
  • There is no need to summarize the case at the beginning of your report;
  • Try to be constructive in your criticism, notably by proposing possible options or solutions to the problems or weaknesses observed;
  • Avoid steering the case away from the teaching objectives established by the authors;
  • Adopt a respectful and polite tone;
  • Be coherent: your detailed comments to the authors should be consistent with your general recommendation to the editor. For example, if you point out one or two weaknesses to the authors, but you recommend rejection of the case to the editor, then you are not being coherent. The same is true if you report major problems in the case or teaching notes in your detailed report, but your recommendation to the editor is “Accept without revision”;
  • Make sure that the authors cannot identify you when reading your report.

+  Submitting your evaluation report

Follow the link to submit your evaluation report.

+  Call for reviewers

The International Journal of Case Studies in Management is seeking the help of faculty members and experts to validate the content of submitted cases. Editorial work is based on the voluntary dedication of peers whose contribution is essential to ensuring the Journal’s quality and academic rigour.

The IJCSM is always looking for experts and professors to interest them in the peer-review process and invite them to register. To register, please click here. This registration does not imply any obligation on your part towards the Journal or vice versa. You may accept or refuse any participation in the peer-review process.

+  List of reviewers

+  2015

  • Arcand, Sébastien (HEC Montréal)
  • Kisfalvi, Veronika (HEC Montréal)
  • Aurier, Philippe (Université de Montpellier)
  • Lalonde, Jean-François (Université de Sherbrooke)
  • Barin Cruz, Luciano (HEC Montréal)
  • Langley, Ann (HEC Montréal)
  • Bédard, François (UQAM)
  • Le Maux, Julien (HEC Montréal)
  • Ben-Hafaïedh, Cyrine (IÉSEG School of Management)
  • Leclercq, Aurélie (IESEG School of management)
  • Ben-Hafaïedh, Cyrine (IÉSEG School of Management)
  • Lemieux, Nathalie (UQAM)
  • Bergeron, François (TELUQ)
  • Line Dubé (HEC Montréal)
  • Bitektine, Alexandre B. (HEC Montréal)
  • Lozeau, Daniel (ENAP)
  • Bouchard, Bruno (UQAR)
  • Luangsay-Catelin, Carine (IUT Dijon Auxerre)
  • Bourdeau, Simon (UQAM)
  • Luc, Sylvain (Université Laval)
  • Boussaguet,Sonia (Reims Management school)
  • MacKenzie, Herbert (Brock University)
  • Bouzinab, Kamal (UQAM)
  • Mailhot, Chantale (HEC Montréal)
  • Bozec, Yves (HEC Montréal)
  • Marcotte, Pascale (UQTR)
  • Camus, Annie (UQAM)
  • Marsan, Josianne (Université Laval)
  • Chamberland, Érick (UQAC)
  • Mazouz, Bachir (ENAP)
  • Charbonneau, Michèle (ENAP)
  • Menvielle, Loïc (UQTR)
  • Chasserio, Stéphanie (SKEMA Business School)
  • Mersereau, Alexander (HEC Montréal)
  • Cloutier, Charlotte (HEC Montréal)
  • Moschieri, Caterina (IE Business School)
  • Coblence, Emmanuel (Institut Supérieur de Gestion de Paris)
  • Murphy, Eileen (ECN Business School)
  • Colovic, Ana (Rouen Business School)
  • Nadeau, Sylvie (ETS)
  • Coulombe, Caroline (UQAM)
  • Nantel, Jacques (HEC Montréal)
  • Cusin, Julien (IAE Bordeaux)
  • Oruezabala, Gwenaëlle (IAE Poitiers)
  • De Corbière, François (École des mines de Nantes)
  • Pai, V.S. (Kirloskar Institute of Advanced Management Studies)
  • Derbaix, Maud (KEDGE Business School)
  • Paulus, Odile (Université de Strasbourg)
  • Dostaler, Isabelle (Concordia)
  • Peerally, Jahan Ara (HEC Montréal)
  • Dupuis, Jean-Pierre (HEC Montréal)
  • Raymond, Benoît (Université Laval)
  • Dupuis, Jérôme (IAE Lille)
  • Rimaud, Marie-Noëlle (ESC La Rochelle)
  • Euzéby, Florence (IAE La Rochelle)
  • Riot, Elen (Reims management school)
  • Fralich, Russell (Saint Mary's University)
  • Ross, Christopher A. (Concordia)
  • Gagnon, Stéphanie (ENAP)
  • Roult, Romain (UQTR)
  • Gendron, Yves (Université Laval)
  • Roy, Marie-Josée (Université Laval)
  • Grogaard, Brigitte (University of Calgary)
  • Senkel, Marie-Pascale (Université de Nantes)
  • Harbour, Michelle (UQO)
  • Sergi, Viviane (UQAM)
  • Hudon, Pierre-André (ENAP)
  • Simon, Laurent (HEC Montréal)
  • Jobin, Marie-Hélène (HEC Montréal)
  • Sponem, Samuel (HEC Montréal)
  • Joly, Allain (HEC Montréal)
  • St-Pierre, Michèle (Université Laval)
  • Karjalainen, Héléna (École de management de Normandie)
  • Thai, Mai Thi Thanh (HEC Montréal)
  • Karjalainen, Héléna (École de management de Normandie)
  • Varaiya, Nikhil (San Diego State Universit)
  • Khechine, Hager (Université Laval)
  • Villeneuve, Jean-Patrick (IDHEAP)

+  2014

  • Bédard, François (UQAM, Canada)
  • Labelle, François (UQTR, Canada)
  • Bergeron, François (UQTR, Canada)
  • Lalonde, Jean-François (Université Sherbrooke, Canada)
  • Bigras, Yvon (UQAM, Canada)
  • Leblond, Patrick (University of Ottawa, Canada)
  • Boujenoui, Ameur (University of Ottawa, Canada)
  • Lemay, Lilly (ENAP, Canada)
  • Bourdeau, Simon (UQAM, Canada)
  • Leroux, Justin (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Bouzinab, Kamal (UQAM, Canada)
  • Luc, Sylvain (Université Laval, Canada)
  • Chasserio, Stéphanie (SKEMA Business School, France)
  • MacKenzie, Herbert (Brock University, Canada)
  • Colovic, Ana (Rouen Business School, France)
  • Marcotte, Pascale (UQTR, Canada)
  • Corbière, François de (École des mines de Nantes, France)
  • Marsan, Josianne (Université Laval, Canada)
  • Côté, André (Université Laval, Canada)
  • Menvielle, Loïc (EDHEC Business School, France)
  • Crié, Dominique (IAE Lille, France)
  • Morin, Denis (UQAM, Canada)
  • Dahan, Jacqueline (Université de Sherbrooke, Canada)
  • Moschieri, Caterina (IE Business School, Espagne)
  • Derbaix, Maud (KEDGE Business School Bordeaux, France)
  • Murphy, Eileen (ECN Business School, France)
  • Dumazert, Jean-Pierre (ESC La Rochelle, France)
  • Nantel, Jacques (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Dupuis, Jérôme (IAE Lille, France)
  • Paulus, Odile (Université de Strasbourg, France)
  • Elia, Elie (UQAM, Canada)
  • Raymond, Benoît (Université Laval, Canada)
  • Euzeby, Florence (IAE La Rochelle, France)
  • Rimaud, Marie-Noëlle (ESC La Rochelle, France)
  • Fralich, Russell (Saint Mary’s University, Canada)
  • Riot, Elen (Reims management school, France)
  • Gendreau, René (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Ross, Christopher A. (Concordia University, Canada)
  • Gendron, Corinne (UQAM, Canada)
  • Roult, Romain (UQTR, Canada)
  • Gilbert, Marie-Hélène (Université Laval, Canada)
  • Sabourin, Vincent (UQAM, Canada)
  • Grogaard, Brigitte (University of Calgary, Canada)
  • Senkel, Marie-Pascale (Université de Nantes, France)
  • Jimenez, Amparo (UQAM, Canada)
  • Sergi, Viviane (UQAM, Canada)
  • Jobin, Marie-Hélène (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Tahssmain, Loubna (ESC La Rochelle, France)
  • Karjalainen, Héléna (École de management de Normandie, France)
  • Thai, Mai Thi Thanh (HEC Montréal, Canada)

+  2013

  • Abdallah, Chaharazad (University of London, United Kingdom)
  • Fortin, Steve (McGill University, Canada)
  • Abraham, Yves-Marie (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Gagnon, Stéphane (UQO, Canada)
  • Aliouat, Boualem (Université de Nice Sophia Antipolis, France)
  • Gagnon, Stéphanie (ENAP, Canada)
  • Ananou, Claude (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Ghadiri, Djahanchah Philip (Sacha) (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Austin, Robert D. (University of New Brunswick, Canada)
  • Haines, Victor (Université de Montréal, Canada)
  • Bareil, Céline (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Hallegatte, Damien (UQAC, Canada)
  • Barin Cruz, Luciano (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Jabali, Ola (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Baron, Louis (UQAM, Canada)
  • Jalette, Patrice (Université de Montréal Canada)
  • Baronet, Jacques (Université de Sherbrooke, Canada)
  • Joly, Allain (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Beaudry, Anne (Concordia University, Canada)
  • Kisfalvi, Veronika (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Beaulieu, Martin (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Lagier, Joëlle (Rouen Business School, France)
  • Béchard, Jean-Pierre (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Lainey, Pierre (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Bélanger-Martin, Luc (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Lapalme, Marie-Ève (UQAM, Canada)
  • Brunelle, Eric (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Legoux, Renaud (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Brunet, Johanne (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Lemieux, Nathalie (UQAM, Canada)
  • Cadieux, Louise (UQTR, Canada)
  • Mailhot, Chantale (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Cameron, Ann-Frances (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Mazouz, Bachir (ENAP, Canada)
  • Camus, Annie (UQAM, Canada)
  • Morin, Danielle (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Cassivi, Luc (UQAM, Canada)
  • Nadeau, Sylvie (ÉTS, Canada)
  • Chamberland, Erick (UQAC, Canada)
  • Ponce, Silvia (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Charbonneau, Michèle (ENAP, Canada)
  • Renault, Micheline (UQAM, Canada)
  • Chartier, Anne (Université Laval, Canada)
  • Robert, Jocelyne (HEC-ULG, Belgique)
  • Chênevert, Denis (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Robert, Jacques (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Cisneros Martinez, Luis Felipe (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Rochette, Corinne (Centre de recherche Clermontois en gestion et management, France)
  • Coblence, Emmanuel (Institut Supérieur de Gestion, Paris, France)
  • Roy, Jacques (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Collerette, Pierre (UQO, Canada)
  • Roy, Francine (Université Sherbrooke, Canada)
  • Corbett, Jacqueline (Université Laval, Canada)
  • Sardais, Cyrille (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Corneiller, Louis (Consultant, Canada)
  • Sénécal, Sylvain (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Delalieux, Guillaume (Université de Lille, France)
  • Shavinina, Larisa (UQO, Canada)
  • Demers, Christiane (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Simon, Laurent (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Denis, Pascale (UQAM, Canada)
  • St-Onge, Sylvie (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Desbiens, Danielle (UQAM, Canada)
  • St-Pierre, Michèle (Université Laval, Canada)
  • Deschênes, Johathan (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Su, Zhan (Université Laval, Canada)
  • Doucet, Olivier (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Talbot, Jean (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Drissi-Kaitouni, Omar (École Mohammadia d’Ingénieurs, Maroc)
  • Thai, Mai Thi Thanh (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Dubé, Line (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Turbide, Johanne (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Dulipovici, Alina Maria (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Tyagi, Rajesh Kumar (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Fabi, Bruno (UQTR, Canada)
  • Veilleux, Sophie (Université Laval, Canada)
  • Facal, Joseph (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Villeneuve, Guy (UQAM, Canada)
  • Fortier, Isabelle (ENAP, Canada)
  • Vincent, Nicolas (HEC Montréal, Canada)

+  2012

  • Aghili, Shaun (Concordia University College of Alberta, Canada)
  • Hébert, Louis (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Amorós Espinosa, José Ernesto (Universidad del Desarrollo, Chili)
  • Henning, Graham K. (Adelphi University, USA)
  • Ananou, Claude (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • King, Brian (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Audebrand, Luc (Université Laval, Canada)
  • Kisfalvi, Veronika (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Austin, Robert D. (University of New Brunswick, Canada)
  • Landry, Guylaine (Université de Sherbrooke, Canada)
  • Bareil, Céline (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Landry, Sylvain (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Barin Cruz, Luciano (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Langley, Ann (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Barrand, Jérôme (École de Management de Grenoble, France)
  • Léger, Pierre-Majorique (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Beaudoin, Michèle (UQAM École supérieure de la mode, Canada)
  • Lemay, Jacques (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Beaulieu, Martin (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Lemay, Lilly (ENAP, Canada)
  • Bégin, Lucie (École de management de Normandie, France)
  • Leroux, Justin (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Boiral, Olivier (Université Laval, Canada)
  • Mailhot, Chantale (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Boisvert, Hugues (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Mandron, Alix (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Bouthillier, Daniel (Kaneq Pharma, Canada)
  • Marion, Stéphane (Université Jean Moulin Lyon 3, France)
  • Bridgman, Todd (Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand)
  • Martel, Louise (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Brunelle, Eric (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Mazouz, Bachir (ENAP, Canada)
  • Calvez, Vincent (ESSCA, France)
  • Mills, Albert (Saint Mary’s University, Canada)
  • Charbonneau (Michèle, ENAP, Canada)
  • Moore, Karl (McGill University, Canada)
  • Chartier, Anne (Université Laval, Canada)
  • Morin, Michel (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Cisneros Martinez, Luis Felipe (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Papadopoulos, Andrew (UQAM, Canada)
  • Claret, Nathalie (Université Paris Sud, France)
  • Parmentier, Marie-Agnès (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Clark, Robert (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Pastoriza Rivas, David (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Cloutier, Charlotte (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Peerally, Jahan Ara (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Cossette, Michel (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Poisson-de Haro, Serge (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Dantas, Danilo C. (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Pomey, Marie-Pascale (Université de Montréal, Canada)
  • Delalieux, Guillaume (Université de Lille, France)
  • Pozzebon, Marlei (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Denis, Pascale (UQAM, Canada)
  • Rakoto, Philémon (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Derry, Robbin (University of Lethbridge, Canada)
  • Raufflet, Emmanuel (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Di Vito, Jacqueline (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Sardais, Cyrille (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Doucet, Olivier (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Sinclair-Desgagné, Bernard (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Dupuis, Jean-Pierre (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Spooner, Marie-Pierre (UQAM, Canada)
  • Durand, Aurélia (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • St-James, Yannik (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Elia, Elie (UQAM, Canada)
  • St-Pierre, Michèle (Université Laval, Canada)
  • Facal, Joseph (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Stréliski, Jean-Jacques (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Fortier, Isabelle (ENAP, Canada)
  • Thai, Mai Thi Thanh (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Fralich, Russell (Saint Mary’s University, Canada)
  • Tiberghien, Bruno (Université Paul Cézanne, France)
  • Gagnon, Stéphanie (ENAP, Canada)
  • Tremblay, Benoit (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Gagnon-Valotaire, Danielle (UQAM, Canada)
  • Turcotte, Marie-France (UQAM, Canada)
  • Gendron, Corinne (UQAM, Canada)
  • Van Assche, Ari (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Ghadiri, Djahanchah Philip (Sacha) (HEC Montréal, Canada)
  • Vézina, Martine (HEC Montréal, Canada)
Share this page :
| Plus

Login or Register

In order to access Case Centre documents, you must be registered with us.
 
Logo HEC Montréal

Facebook YouTube Flickr Twitter LinkedIn Instagram
© HEC Montréal, 2017  All rights reserved.